Imagine being one of rock's all-time legends, yet still feeling like a wide-eyed fan in the presence of true genius—that's exactly how Tom Petty felt around two songwriting icons who left him in awe. If you've ever wondered who could make a master like Petty admit to feeling intimidated, stick around; this story reveals the songwriters he placed on an unreachable pedestal.
Tom Petty built an incredible legacy over more than 40 years, crafting timeless hits not just for his own band, the Heartbreakers, but also for collaborations and side projects that dotted his career. For beginners dipping into music history, songwriting is like painting with words and melodies—it's a craft that's easy to try but incredibly tough to master, which explains why only a handful of names dominate the conversation. Petty was undeniably one of those elite few, earning his spot as one of America's top-selling and most influential artists. Think of early breakthroughs like the energetic 'American Girl,' which captured the thrill of youth, or the soaring 'Free Fallin'' from the '80s, a perfect slice of heartfelt rock that still resonates today. Coming from Florida, Petty's creativity seemed limitless, blending storytelling with catchy hooks that felt both personal and universal.
As his fame grew, Petty rubbed shoulders with some of the biggest names in music, but nothing compared to the thrill—and nerves—of working with his idols. This peaked during his time with The Traveling Wilburys, that legendary supergroup from the late '80s that teamed up rock royalty like George Harrison, Roy Orbison, Jeff Lynne, and yes, Bob Dylan. For those new to this era, the Wilburys were like a dream jam session where egos took a backseat to pure creativity, producing albums full of witty, rootsy tunes.
At the heart of it for Petty was Bob Dylan, the folk legend he once called the greatest writer alive. In a chat with author Paul Zollo, Petty opened up about the experience: "It was scary, you know, because you're sharing the stage with the greatest writer who ever lived." He admitted it threw him off at first—"It really intimidated me"—but after a few performances, he settled in, focusing on the music rather than the myth. And here's where it gets controversial: Dylan's influence is so massive that almost every songwriter since the '70s owes him a nod, from his poetic lyrics tackling social issues to his raw, ever-evolving style. Not everyone wins a Nobel Prize in Literature for their songs, like Dylan did in 2016, which sparked endless debates about whether music qualifies as high art. Petty, who grew up idolizing Dylan's early '60s folk explosion—think albums like The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan that mixed protest anthems with intimate ballads—couldn't help but absorb that revolutionary spirit into his own work.
But Dylan wasn't the only '60s trailblazer who shaped Petty's sound. Like any songwriter worth their salt, Petty had a profound respect for The Beach Boys, especially their brilliant frontman, Brian Wilson. And this is the part most people miss: while Dylan ruled the introspective folk world, Wilson was revolutionizing pop with sunny harmonies and innovative studio tricks. In 1966, Wilson's masterpiece Pet Sounds dropped, an album that pushed boundaries with orchestral arrangements, emotional depth, and tracks like 'God Only Knows' and 'Wouldn't It Be Nice'—it's often hailed as one of the greatest records ever, influencing everyone from The Beatles to modern indie acts.
Petty was a huge fan, once telling Playboy magazine, "Brian Wilson is the greatest." He put Wilson right up there with Dylan, praising how Pet Sounds took huge risks: "The root of his personal problem was that he did genius work and never got the recognition from everyday folks. So he took a real artistic risk. It's a brilliant album." For context, Wilson battled mental health struggles amid the pressure to top his own innovations, yet his vision created a blueprint for ambitious pop that Petty clearly admired and drew from in his own melodic, narrative-driven songs.
Naming just two songwriters as the absolute best is sure to stir up arguments—who wouldn't want to throw names like Lennon, McCartney, or even Petty himself into the mix? Boldly put, Dylan's lyrical prowess and Wilson's production wizardry are tough to top, but what if we consider how their personal demons fueled their art? Without them, the rock landscape that birthed Petty and countless others would look wildly different, missing those layers of innovation and heart.
So, what do you think—does Dylan and Wilson truly stand above the rest, or is there another songwriter you'd crown king? Drop your thoughts in the comments; I'd love to hear if you agree with Petty or have a hot take to challenge it!
(Credits: Far Out / The Bigger Picture)
Sun 28 December 2025 17:30, UK
Related Topics
Never Miss A Tale
The Far Out Bob Dylan Newsletter
All the latest stories about Bob Dylan from the independent voice of culture.
Straight to your inbox.
